Running a successful business means handling both predictable expenses and unexpected obligations. Workplace injuries are one such uncertainty. A single incident may lead to medical expenses, wage replacement, and prolonged claims that place additional pressure on an employer’s budget.
According to the National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI), lost-time workers’ compensation claim frequency declined by an estimated 2% in 2025. At the same time, medical and indemnity claims each increased by 4% across NCCI states.
This makes it important to anticipate future claims costs as part of insurance planning and the workers’ compensation loss pick process. Loss picks help insurers estimate potential losses using historical claims experience, loss development, and other relevant factors.
Understanding how these estimates are developed can help make better decisions about workers’ compensation coverage and risk management. This guide explores the information required, the calculation process, and how employers can use loss projections effectively.
Gathering the right information before loss pick is calculated
An understanding of the business’ past claims experience and current risk exposure is important for calculating loss pick. Reliable records are needed to account for outstanding claims and predict factors that may influence future losses. The following information serves as a good place to start:
- Historical claims records: Gather workers’ compensation claims data from previous policy years to identify recurring injuries and costly incidents.
- Paid losses and outstanding reserves: Review amounts already paid alongside estimated future payments for existing claims.
- Payroll and employee classifications: Collect payroll figures and employee job classifications, as workplace size and occupational risks influence workers’ compensation exposure.
- Claim frequency and severity: Assess how often workplace injuries occur and how much they cost.
- Claims development and industry trends: Consider how outstanding claims may develop over time, along with changes in medical expenses and wages.
According to a recent AM Best report, workers’ compensation insurers recorded a combined ratio of 93.2 in 2025. Favorable loss development on older accident years contributed significantly to their underwriting profitability.
The report also highlighted concerns regarding weak reserve adequacy. David Blades, Associate Director at AM Best, explained, “While reserves remain redundant, the redundancy has been dissipating and is now at its lowest level since 2021. The next 12 months will provide significant insight into whether this is a trend.”
Claims estimates are just that, not fixed figures. Employers need to maintain updated records and account for the development of outstanding claims. With this information organized, it gets easier to make well-informed assumptions about future losses.
How to calculate loss pick step by step

A loss pick is an estimate of the claims costs an insurer expects to incur for a particular business, policy period, or group of exposures. In workers’ compensation, it helps insurers assess potential future losses using historical claims data, outstanding reserves, and other relevant factors.
The phrase loss pick insurance refers to this estimating process within insurance and risk management. It is not a separate insurance product or type of coverage that employers can purchase. Instead, a loss pick is a projection used to support decisions about insurance pricing, reserves, and financial exposure.
Although insurers and actuaries usually handle formal loss-pick calculations, understanding the process behind a workers’ compensation loss pick is useful for employers. They can see how their claims history and business operations influence these estimates. Here are the main steps involved:
- Start by reviewing claims from previous policy periods. Check both paid amounts and outstanding reserves to understand the past and the future.
- Estimate the ultimate cost of existing claims. This is important because medical treatment or rehabilitation may continue long after an injury is reported. As Prescient National points out, workers’ compensation claims can, in some cases, take years to be settled. This means their estimated costs may have to be adjusted over time.
- Modify for changing costs and conditions. Enlyte’s 2026 analysis found that average medical costs per workers’ compensation claimant increased by 9.5% between 2022 and 2025, reaching $4398 in 2025. Besides medical costs, service utilization and treatment patterns also influence the final price of a claim.
- Account for a business’s current exposure. Consider whether the business has expanded its workforce, opened new facilities, or introduced stronger safety measures.
- Develop the expected loss estimate. This estimate will reflect the expected losses for the defined period and exposure, rather than simply adding up previous claim payments.
A simple example
Suppose a business has an estimated ultimate loss of $200,000 based on its historical claims experience. If its payroll and workforce exposure are expected to increase by 10%, an actuary might consider that change when projecting future losses.
A simplified illustration would be: $200,000 x 1.10 = $220,000
The resulting figure ($220,000) is an illustrative projection, not a definitive workers’ compensation loss pick. The actual calculation would also account for relevant loss development, changes in the workforce’s risk profile, and the actuarial method being used.
What your loss pick reveals about insurance costs and financial exposure

Besides estimating future claim costs, a loss pick helps employers understand how their claims experience may influence workers’ compensation costs and financial obligations. Higher expected losses can indicate greater potential exposure, which insurers may consider when evaluating coverage and pricing.
A 2026 report published in the Insurance Journal found that California workers’ compensation insurers recorded a projected combined ratio of 127% for 2025, the highest in over 20 years. The report linked this result to higher claim frequency and increasing loss and loss-adjustment expenses.
For employers, a loss pick can offer useful insights into several areas of financial planning. The table below will give a better understanding:
| Financial area | What the loss pick reveals |
|---|---|
| Insurance premiums | How expected claims may influence the insurer’s assessment of risk and coverage costs |
| Deductibles and retained losses | Potential claims expenses an employer may need to fund under a loss-sensitive arrangement |
| Reserves and collateral | Potential future claim liabilities and collateral requirements under certain insurance programs |
| Budgeting and cash flow | How much financial room may be needed for claims-related expenses |
| Risk management | Recurring or costly claims that may require stronger workplace safety measures |
However, a loss pick does not determine an employer’s final premium. Actual insurance costs also depend on payroll, classification rates, policy terms, and the type of coverage. For instance, employers generally pay an agreed premium under traditional guaranteed-cost coverage. On the other hand, loss-sensitive programs link some insurance costs more closely to actual claims experience. Understanding the loss pick helps employers evaluate their potential financial exposure and make more informed coverage/budgeting decisions.
How employers can keep their loss projections on track

You calculate a loss pick; you put it aside and forget all about it: This cannot be done. As claims develop, workforce conditions change, and new risks emerge, earlier estimates may need to be reviewed. Employers can help keep these projections relevant by maintaining reliable records and staying involved in the claims management process.
A few practical measures can make a meaningful difference. These may include:
- Maintaining an updated claims record, including reported injuries, medical expenses, and outstanding reserves
- Reporting workplace injuries promptly, as delays can complicate the claims handling process
- Reviewing outstanding claims regularly to check whether reserves reflect the latest developments
- Investing in workplace safety through employee training, equipment maintenance, and safer work procedures
- Monitoring changes in business operations, such as workforce expansion or new job responsibilities
The value of proactive injury prevention was highlighted in a 2026 National Safety Council study, as reported by Claims Journal. Among the surveyed 405 non-managerial workers, nearly 70% experienced job-related musculoskeletal disorder symptoms. 56% of those who used robots for injury prevention said that these technologies reduced such symptoms.
Employers need to identify ergonomic risks and explore practical ways to prevent injuries. It’s equally important to arrange periodic reviews with insurers and brokers. Comparing projected losses with actual claims experience can reveal whether risk management measures are working as intended.
FAQs
What information is needed to estimate future workers’ compensation losses?
Employers need historical claims records, paid losses, outstanding reserves, and information about claim frequency and severity. Changes in business operations and industry trends also help insurers develop more realistic estimates.
Who is responsible for calculating expected workers’ compensation losses?
Insurers and actuaries generally prepare formal estimates using historical claims data, loss development factors, business exposure, and changing costs. Employers support the process by providing accurate records and regularly reviewing claims information.
How can employers reduce their future workers’ compensation costs?
Employers can strengthen workplace safety, provide employee training, report incidents promptly, and review outstanding claims. These measures can help prevent injuries, improve claims management, and support more informed insurance and budgeting decisions.
Wrapping up
Ultimately, a loss pick enables employers to understand how workplace risks and changing claim expenses can influence future finances. According to the US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), private industry employers reported 2.5 million non-fatal workplace injuries and illnesses in 2024.
That was a 3.1% decline from 2023. The total recordable case rate also fell to 2.3 cases per 100 full-time equivalent workers. This was the lowest level since the data series began in 2003. The progress is promising, but employers still need to prepare for the financial impact of individual claims and changing risk exposures.
By maintaining accurate claims records and investing in workplace safety, businesses can make more informed insurance decisions. A well-developed loss pick does not eliminate uncertainty, but it helps employers prepare for it with greater clarity and financial confidence.

















