Reading Time: 6 minutes

How a Non-Qualified Annuity Can Affect Your Retirement Taxes

Non-Qualified Annuity Taxes: How They Affect Retirement Income | The Enterprise World
In This Article

Imagine retiring with several income sources ready to support you. Social Security may cover some monthly bills, while savings and investments help pay for the rest. You may also have a non-qualified annuity funded with money you already paid taxes on.

Its earnings grow tax-deferred, giving you flexibility over when you receive taxable income. The timing and size of a distribution can shape your annual tax bill. A large withdrawal may also affect your Medicare premiums, depending on your income and the rules in effect.

Understanding these details about non-qualified annuity taxes before you take money can help you make choices with fewer surprises. Your annuity’s tax treatment, payment options, and place in your retirement plan all matter.

Tax-deferred growth and retirement savings decisions

A non-qualified annuity lets you invest after-tax money and defer taxes on its earnings. You generally don’t pay yearly income tax on gains inside the contract. Taxes usually apply when you take taxable distributions.

Tax deferral can affect when you report investment income and non-qualified annuity taxes. Review the contract’s costs, payout terms, and access rules before deciding whether it fits your retirement needs. Retirement income planning also involves deciding how to turn savings into steady payments.

The Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI) explored this interest in its 2024 Retirement Confidence Survey. Among workers participating in workplace retirement plans, 83% were interested in using savings for guaranteed monthly income.

Meanwhile, 53% of workers expected a guaranteed-income product to provide retirement income, compared with 28% of retirees who reported receiving it. About 1 in 7 retirees had used a product guaranteeing monthly income for life.

These figures cover guaranteed-income products broadly, rather than non-qualified annuities alone. They suggest a gap between workers’ expectations and retirees’ reported experiences.

When comparing savings options, consider how each product could support your retirement income needs. Review its tax treatment and access rules to judge whether tax-deferred growth fits your plan.

Annuity payments and their taxable portions

Non-Qualified Annuity Taxes: How They Affect Retirement Income | The Enterprise World
Source – johnstevenson.com

Your annuity’s tax treatment depends on how you receive its money. Periodic payments can include taxable income and a tax-free return of your investment. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) calls this method the General Rule for certain annuity payments.

Under this rule, the IRS compares your investment in the contract with its expected return. The exclusion percentage determines how much of each payment you can receive tax-free. For example, say your investment is $10,800, and your expected return is $24,000.

Your exclusion percentage would be 45%. If you receive $1,200 in annual payments, $540 is tax-free. The remaining $660 generally counts as taxable income. IRS Publication 939 explains this method.

For contracts starting after 1986, the total tax-free amount generally cannot exceed your net investment. Withdrawals before annuitization follow a different tax order. According to 1891 Financial Life, earnings generally come out first and are taxed as ordinary income.

Before taking money from a non-qualified annuity, review its withdrawal terms. This can help you estimate the taxable amount before requesting a distribution.

Annuity income and Medicare premium adjustments

Your retirement income can shape both your tax bill and your Medicare costs. Higher income may raise your Medicare Part B and prescription drug premiums. These added charges are called income-related monthly adjustment amounts, or IRMAA.

The Social Security Administration (SSA) uses modified adjusted gross income to determine whether these adjustments apply. This figure includes adjusted gross income and tax-exempt interest.

SSA generally uses tax information from two years earlier to determine your Medicare premiums. This means your current premiums may reflect income from an earlier year.

For 2026, people with modified adjusted gross income above $109,000 may pay higher premiums. Married couples filing jointly face a threshold of $218,000. Your premium depends on your income level and filing status.

Taxable annuity income can add to your adjusted gross income, so a large distribution may affect Medicare costs and non-qualified annuity taxes. Your premium depends on your total income and the annual rules.

Before taking a large distribution, check the relevant income thresholds and consider your expected income and Medicare coverage. If a qualifying life-changing event lowers your income, you may ask SSA to adjust your premium.

Retirement timing and annuity income decisions

Non-Qualified Annuity Taxes: How They Affect Retirement Income | The Enterprise World
Source – investopedia.com

Your retirement date, Social Security claim, and annuity payments affect when you receive income and draw from savings. Research from the Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association of America (TIAA) Institute examined these decisions using Health and Retirement Study data.

The study found that retiring and claiming Social Security at the same time became less common. The same trend appeared among people starting Social Security and a life annuity together.

The study also linked more generous rewards for delaying Social Security with later claims. Poor health, however, was associated with earlier retirement and earlier claims. For people who retire before claiming Social Security, the delay creates an income gap they must cover.

Retirement researcher Wade Pfau explains, “If you are delaying Social Security, you’ll probably need to draw from investments.” The size of that gap depends on your retirement date, spending needs, and other income sources.

Use those factors to plan when you’ll draw from savings and when Social Security may begin. Then review how your annuity’s payment options fit that timeline. Check the contract terms before choosing.

Retirement tax and annuity data by the numbers

Workplace Guaranteed Income Interest (EBRI)83% worker interest; 53% expect it vs. 28% of retirees receiving it
IRS General Rule Exclusion Ratio (IRS Pub. 939)Exclusion percentage determines tax-free return of basis vs. taxable earnings
Medicare IRMAA Thresholds (SSA)2-year lookback; surcharges begin above $109,000 (single) and $218,000 (joint)
Retirement and Claiming Timing (TIAA Institute)Decoupling of retirement and benefit claims; bridge funding required for delays

Give your retirement plan room to grow

Non-Qualified Annuity Taxes: How They Affect Retirement Income | The Enterprise World
Source – eliteincomeadvisors.com

Your retirement plans may change as your priorities, responsibilities, and daily routines shift. A decision that feels right today may need another look when your circumstances change.

Give yourself room to review your plan periodically and make adjustments with care. The aim is to build a retirement life that feels manageable, with enough flexibility to respond to unexpected expenses or new priorities.

If a financial decision feels unclear, speak with a qualified professional who can help you weigh your options.

Did You like the post? Share it now: